Pale blue-gray cottage porch with white posts, red brick foundation, concrete steps and a shaded garden beside a lawn.

Thelma's Kitchen Is Alabama's Best Fried Chicken, Says Yelp. What That Ranking Actually Counted.

"The fried catfish, greens, and lima beans, and the fried chicken (came fresh while we were eating) were all delicious. We stopped while traveling and will definitely come back."

That's the line Business Insider picked from Yelp user Spring O. to explain why Thelma's Kitchen in Eufaula is Alabama's entry on its national list of the best fried chicken shop in every state. Look at what she ordered. The chicken shows up fourth, after the catfish, greens and lima beans, and it came out fresh while she was eating.

Yelp's top-ranked fried chicken in Alabama comes from a cafeteria-style soul food kitchen on Mack Street, where the chicken is one dish on a full Southern line.

How the List Was Built

Business Insider put the list together with Yelp, and the page shows an update stamp of October 7, 2026. The method fits in three steps, laid out in the article itself:

  1. Yelp searched its restaurant and food categories for businesses with a high concentration of reviews mentioning "fried chicken."
  2. It ranked those businesses on several factors, including review volume and ratings.
  3. Where health scores were available, every restaurant on the list had a passing score as of September 24, 2026. Chains with several locations appeared only once, at their highest-ranked spot.

The article doesn't publish a weighting formula, so nobody outside Yelp knows exactly how volume was balanced against stars. Even so, the first step tells you a lot. A restaurant doesn't need "chicken" in its name or a chicken-only menu to qualify. It needs people who write Yelp reviews to keep bringing up the fried chicken, and to rate the place well when they do.

For a cafeteria line that rotates comfort food daily, that's a high bar. A reviewer at Thelma's could just as easily write about the catfish or the collards. For the restaurant to show up as a fried chicken spot, the chicken has to keep standing out from everything around it on the line, and the review Business Insider quoted shows how that happens. It came out of the kitchen fresh while the customer was still eating.

What's on the Line

AL.com's October 12 story on the ranking calls Thelma's a cafeteria-style soul food restaurant with a daily menu of comfort food: ribs, fried catfish and fried chicken, plus freshly made Southern sides like mac 'n cheese, fried okra and collard greens. The same piece notes lunch specials and steak dinners on the weekend, and it describes Thelma's as beloved by locals and visitors alike.

Business Insider's "what to order" line names two dishes, fried chicken and fried catfish. On a list built around one dish, the editors still felt the catfish deserved the same billing. That says something about the kitchen. A first visit built only around the award would miss half of what Business Insider recommended.

Here's a practical way to plan a first plate based on what both outlets describe:

  • Chicken and catfish together, the two dishes Business Insider recommends by name
  • Greens and lima beans, the sides in the quoted review
  • Mac 'n cheese or fried okra, both on AL.com's list of house-made sides
  • A Friday or Saturday evening if you want the weekend steak dinner AL.com mentions instead of the cafeteria lunch

The Company Thelma's Keeps on the List

The neighbors on the list help show what Yelp's method rewards. AL.com points out several other state picks, including Mrs. Wilkes' Dining Room in Savannah, Georgia; The Eagle in Louisville; Shaya in New Orleans; Walnut Hills in Vicksburg, Mississippi; Magnolia 23 in Asheboro, North Carolina; Page's Okra Grill in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina; and Monell's Dining & Catering in Nashville.

That roster leans heavily toward restaurants built around Southern home cooking with plenty of sides. For anyone in the Chattahoochee Valley, Georgia's pick is the closest comparison. Mrs. Wilkes' in Savannah is the pick for the state across the river, and Thelma's on Mack Street now has the same credential for Alabama.

The full set of picks is also on Yelp's own collection page, and Thelma's has its Yelp listing, where the reviews behind the ranking can be read.

Check the Hours Before You Go

A ranking that relies on review volume tends to bring more reviewers. Spring O. described herself as someone who "stopped while traveling," and a national list puts Thelma's in front of more people making that same stop. Eufaula residents heading over in the weeks after the news should check the hours first, because the published hours don't agree.

Day Hours per AL.com, Oct. 12, 2026 Hours per Restaurantji, updated Sept. 16, 2026
Tuesday to Thursday 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. 11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. 11 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Sunday 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. 11 a.m. to 7 p.m.

The sources agree on midweek and Sunday. They disagree on the two later nights, and those happen to be the nights AL.com ties to the steak dinners. Restaurantji's listing shows a 7 p.m. close every open day. AL.com shows 9 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. If a weekend steak dinner is the plan, check Thelma's Kitchen on Facebook, which AL.com names as the place for current information, before you drive over late. Restaurantji lists Thelma's as closed on Mondays, and AL.com's schedule doesn't include Monday either.

Thelma's is at 26 Mack Street. Mack Street connects to State Route 30 south of where the route crosses Broad Street downtown. A Toast listing for the restaurant gives a broad $1 to $15 price range but no itemized menu, so expect to see prices on the line itself.

The Rest of Eufaula's Plate-Lunch Table

Thelma's isn't Eufaula's only cafeteria-style lunch, and the ranking makes it easier to see the format they share. Barb's Country Kitchen runs a country buffet with a choice of meats, fresh vegetables and desserts, according to its Tripadvisor listing. A reviewer in September 2025 called it cafeteria-style meat-and-three Southern cooking and singled out the fried chicken, and another reviewer wrote about the fried chicken there in May 2026. Call ahead for Barb's current location and hours before you go.

Out at the lake, the Water's Edge dining room at Lakepoint State Park is the buffet version of the same idea. Alabama State Parks describes a seasonal schedule with Thursday and Sunday lunch buffets and a Friday seafood buffet. Since the schedule is seasonal, check the park's page before planning a fall lunch around it.

At all three, you build your own plate from a spread of Southern meats and vegetables. Yelp's method surfaced the one whose chicken kept coming up in reviews. The spotlight went to Mack Street, but this kind of cooking is served in more than one dining room around town.

One more Eufaula restaurant appears on a recent regional list. The "Back Road Bites" flavor trail from Alabama Black Belt Adventures includes Cajun Corner and highlights its North Shore Pasta and blackened grouper sandwich. The trail page was last updated August 14, 2026.

The Order, Once More

If you've never been, Business Insider's advice comes down to two dishes, the fried chicken and the fried catfish. AL.com's description adds greens or fried okra on the side and a weekend steak dinner if the evening hours check out. Start with the chicken that won the title and the catfish that got equal billing, then pick whatever sides look best on the line that day.

When out-of-town friends or family ask where to eat in Eufaula, it helps to have a better answer than whatever the top search result says. At Chattahoochee Realty Group, we live and work here, and we're happy to tell you which Mack Street lunch line and which lakeside buffet to plan a visit around. Get Exclusive Access to Top Listings, and get the local tips that come with them.

Where You Belong

Helping clients find more than just a home—creating lasting relationships and enriching the community one connection at a time.

Follow Me on Instagram